We Must Hold Them Accountable for the Qana Children

Submitted by Jonathan Tasini on July 31, 2006 - 11:19am.

Let’s get one thing straight: the killing of dozens of children in Qana was an inevitable result of an aggressive aerial bombing campaign. Last week, I tried to warn our political leaders that our country could not stand by idly as Israel launched a massive attack that was sure to cause heavy civilian casualties. I was one of the few candidates for political office who called for an immediate ceasefire and condemned the violence on both sides: the firing of missiles by Hezbollah and the dropping of bombs by Israel. Instead of calling for restraint or a ceasefire, however, my opponent, Hillary Clinton, tried to Swift-boat me, dispatching her political operatives to lie about what I had said.

In a sense, I understand why my opponent has to try to silence the truth. She, and a broad segment of our political leadership, bear responsibility for the deaths of these children. They gave cover for what many rank-and-file Israeli citizens (and some Israeli politicians) are now calling a moral and military debacle. The Bush Administration stood by while a large part of infrastructure of Lebanon was reduced to rubble. Rather than call for restraint, Hillary Clinton stopped just short of declaring “let the bombs fall” with a one-sided statement that only helped fan the flames of violence.

So, I am not backing down. I am repeating what I said before: we must end the violence. Our country must reverse its one-sided policy in the Middle East and push aggressively for a strong, independent, economically viable Palestinian state existing along side a strong, independent, economically vibrant Israel. It is the only solution that will bring peace to the civilians who now live in fear of death raining down from above.

I remind people that my father was a proud fighter in the Israeli underground in 1948 and fought for its founding. Half my family lives in Israel. Indeed, a cousin of mine was killed in 1973 war and my step-grandfather was murdered by a Palestinian, for the simple reason he was a Jew. I know what it is like to sit in a bomb shelter or touch the body of a person killed by war. Has Hillary Clinton or other so-called “friends of Israel,” who have cheered for armed conflict and death and destruction, ever spent one night in fear from war or sobbing in sorrow because of the death of a loved one in war? For them, it is all about political calculations, pandering and votes.

Was it worth it? Was it worth it to poison the Lebanese environment with spilled and burning oil, toxic waste flows, piled up garbage that will spread diseases? The death of hundreds of civilians, the flattening of entire towns and a huge portion of southern Beirut, the destruction of hundreds of millions of dollars of civilian infrastructure, and the creation of a two-mile dead zone at the Lebanese border—none of this is going to make my relatives in Israel any safer from Katyusha and Fajr missile attacks in the future. This war has unified the Lebanese and much of the world against Israel, many of whom just a month ago despised Hezbollah—and has done relatively little to weaken the militia’s power and appeal. Real security will come when we finally recognize that Israel’s future is inextricably linked to a just resolution to the Palestinian people’s legitimate demands for safety, security, and self-determination.

I want to guarantee Israel’s long-term peace and security, as well as the peace and security of the Palestinians and the Lebanese. We can’t ever do so with an approach that mimics the Bush Administration’s imperial, oil-driven Middle East agenda. Last week George Bush sent Condoleeza Rice to the Rome peace conference for one purpose – to single-handedly derail the agreement for a cease-fire. Even by the Bush Administration’s already low standards, this was truly an embarrassment and a disgrace. But, we must also reject Hillary Clinton-style politics that allows itself to be held hostage to the blind ideology of the ultra-right-wing fundamentalist settlers and their supporters, who hold too much power.

American Jews such as myself will have to gain the courage to speak out against unjust and ineffectual policies that play into the extremist agenda on both sides. If you want to gain any hope from my experience, it’s worth noting that since my first statement last week, we have been deluged with calls and emails; they are running 10-1 in favor of my position, almost all from Jewish Americans. There is hope. We must reject the same old pandering and lies, and turn instead to real, principled leadership, for a just and lasting peace for the children of Israel and Palestine. Let us resolve to make the children of Qana the last innocent people to see their lives end violently and needlessly.



Submitted by Scott (not registered) on July 31, 2006 - 10:32pm.

A thoughtful discussion of the ongoing crisis in the Middle East appears in a full-page ad in today's New York Times. The signatories include religious leaders, scholars, poets and activists.

This ad proposes an immediate cessation of military attacks and a cease fire by Israel, Hezbollah and Hamas; an international embargo on shipments of weapons to all parties; and an international conference to provide security on the border between Israel and Lebanon.

The full text of this ad can be found at www.tikkun.org.

Submitted by Jean (not registered) on August 1, 2006 - 2:15am.

Please keep speaking out. Yes, the American political leadership is responsible for the death and destruction in Lebanon.

As I mentioned in an earlier comment, I've been watching your and Ned Lamont's campaigns from abroad. Lamont's recent statements in support of Israeli war crimes were shameful, and completely inconsistent with his purported opposition to the American occupation of Iraq. American foreign policy, particularly in the Middle East, needs to be thoroughly reformed. In particular, the pathologically pro-Israel stance of virtually all of Congress and the White House must be changed. What a perversion not only of the political system, but of reality, not to mention moraliity, when your criticism of Israel is considered "beyond the pale", while Israel's war crimes are unquestioningly accepted and even supported.

Hillary Clinton and the many others like her have to go. They are, truly, beyond the pale.

Submitted by John Francis Lee (not registered) on August 4, 2006 - 10:52am.

When you're on NY1, please remember to point out that it is no more in American's interests than it is in Israelis' to keep the Israeli Entitlement Fund, and with it the permanent war in defense of injustice going in the Middle East.

In fact, really dangerous events are bound to follow this "adventure" of Israel's, so reminiscent of our own American neocons' adventure in Iraq. The Shia of Iraq are understandably furious at the US/Israeli Axis for its destruction of Lebanon and with it the Shia population of that nation. The US troops in Iraq have survived thus far due to Shia forebearance. That forebearance is rapidly coming to an end. The Shia control the south of Iraq, and the 400 - 800 mile supply line for American forces snakes through their territory. Once they stand up against us, and they will because Hillary and the rest of the Demoplicans refuse to confront not the Republicrats but their AIPAC bosses, they will sever that supply line and the Americans will leave Iraq, finally, by helicopter from the roof of the US embassy.

Frankly our only hope at this point is that Russia and China together prevail upon Iran not to rise to the US/Israeli bait, to keep a lid on their talk even, and then that R&C make it clear to the US/UK/Israeli Axis that they are up against the combined armed might of the civilized world if they destroy Iran as they have Lebanon, just as John Kennedy did in 1962 to Khruschev.

Relying on Russian and China. Can you believe our political class has left us in these staits?

We have seen the enemy and he is us!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
More information about formatting options